The gang jumps to a conclusion
A newspaper reports allegations against Mac and Charlie’s former coach. Charlie’s reaction leads Dennis and Dee to assume he was abused and appoint themselves his counselors.
Supporting source ↗CASE FILE · S01 E07

The gang thinks Charlie may have been molested by his high-school gym teacher, so they stage an intervention, and invite Charlie's family and other alleged victims.
THE SHORT VERSION · SPOILERS AHEAD
A newspaper reports allegations against Mac and Charlie’s former coach. Charlie’s reaction leads Dennis and Dee to assume he was abused and appoint themselves his counselors.
Supporting source ↗The brothers tell Charlie that their allegation is fabricated. They want revenge and money, and threaten to implicate him if he tells the police.
Supporting source ↗Bonnie, Uncle Jack and other relatives gather with the gang and the McPoyles. Bonnie brings out a doll, leaving Charlie surrounded by an unwanted audience.
Supporting source ↗Charlie reports the brothers instead of joining their claim. Dennis and Dee congratulate themselves, while Charlie points out that their assumptions have damaged his reputation.
Supporting source ↗THE EVIDENCE
Bonnie stands at the front of the family gathering.Source ↗
Charlie speaks to an officer with the McPoyle brothers at his side.Source ↗
Coach Murray talks with Mac on the couch in his home.Source ↗
Dee watches the intervention beside Liam McPoyle.Source ↗
Dennis holds a pool cue while attempting to draw Charlie into a conversation.Source ↗
Liam waits at the station wearing a sleeveless denim jacket.Source ↗
Mac visits Coach Murray in a fitted blue shirt and running shorts.Source ↗
Ryan waits beside Liam in a brown jacket.Source ↗
The detective in a pale shirt stands behind Charlie after their interview.Source ↗
The gray-haired officer with a moustache writes at the counter while addressing Charlie.Source ↗
Uncle Jack sits with Charlie’s family during the intervention.Source ↗
The McPoyle brothers wait together at the police station.Source ↗
Coach Murray receives Mac at his front door.Source ↗
Dennis and Dee sit on the apartment’s black leather couch while Mac talks.Source ↗
The gang reads about the allegations during a quiet morning at the bar.Source ↗
Charlie and the McPoyles arrive together at the station’s front desk.Source ↗
The newspaper names St. Vincent’s Elementary; the school is only mentioned.Source ↗
Charlie sits opposite the towel-wearing brother in the McPoyles’ living room.Source ↗
Dennis and Dee cite their psychology studies at Penn.Source ↗
A bicycle leans behind the couch in Mac and Dennis’s apartment.Source ↗
Mac stands beside a stack of books on the bar during his research explanation.Source ↗
An ornate oval mirror hangs behind Bonnie in the dining area.Source ↗
Mac studies the newspaper spread across a table at Paddy’s.Source ↗
Mac holds printed photographs while talking with Dennis and Dee.Source ↗
Dennis and Dee talk with Charlie beside the green-felt table.Source ↗
Dennis holds a green beer bottle during the apartment discussion.Source ↗
The McPoyles threaten to blame Charlie if he exposes their fabricated claim.Source ↗
The brothers admit that their accusation against Murray is a revenge and compensation scheme.Source ↗
Dennis and Dee assemble Charlie’s family for an intervention based on their assumption about him.Source ↗
Liam enters the room in a striped bathrobe while Charlie visits Ryan.Source ↗
Mac wears short blue athletic shorts when visiting Coach Murray.Source ↗
Dee discusses Dr. Gainer with Dennis; he does not appear.Source ↗
Tags document researched occurrences, not every appearance. Read the research notes and attribution.